The design review a site gets before a client sees it
A page can pass every check on a list and still not be good. That is why a site of ours gets two reviews before a client sees it: a design read by a person, and a written QA sheet. The sheet says whether the page works. The read says whether it is right.
The design read
These are the questions a person answers by looking, on the real page, before anyone else does.
- Does it hold at the widths people use? We open the page fresh at each width, from desktop down to a phone, rather than dragging one window narrower. Dragging is how we once got a false result on our own calculator, and fresh loads are how we found our contact page running off the screen between 528 and 568 pixels, and again at 864 and 872. We wrote that one up.
- Can every line of text over a picture be read? We look at the real card at a desktop width and at 375 pixels. A contrast number can pass while a busy picture still makes a title hard to read.
- Does the main picture say something at a glance? Would a stranger name the subject at once? Does it look real?
- Is anything there that should not be? Text inside an image, a stray logo, a placeholder, a link that goes to the wrong place.
- Can you reach everything with the keyboard, and see where you are? Our post on four accessibility checks a scanner cannot settle has the method.
The hardest question is the last one: is this good, or only done? A change list can prove that each requested change was made. It cannot prove that the result is better than what it replaced. So a person looks at the result itself, next to what it replaces, not only at the list of changes.
The sheet
Then the page goes through the written QA sheet: eleven checks in the same order every time, from layout at four widths to a failure we provoke on purpose to prove the checks can fail. We described the sheet and the routine around it in How we maintain WordPress sites on Kinsta.
The sheet is honest about one limit. It covers whether the build matches what was agreed. Whether the design is right stays the client’s call, or the agency’s. The read is there so that, when the client makes that call, they are judging the design, not finding our mistakes.
What this gives an agency
If you hand us overflow work, you get the page and the sheet, without our branding, before the invoice.
Book a 30-minute call on our Agencies page and bring one page you would hand over first.
Gráfica built this survey as a WordPress plugin, and builds plugins like it for clients. Tell us what your site needs